A 50-year-old previously healthy man presented to our hospital with acute onset total right sided facial tingling and weakness. Prior to hospitalization, patient had presented to his primary doctor three weeks prior for painful paresthesias of his low back, right hip, right buttocks, and left thigh. His primary doctor ordered a hip XR, which was negative, and prescribed Flexeril. Due to persistent pain and paresthesias, patient was then started on prednisone, and he then developed a right facial droop, pressure-like headache, and double vision leading to his presentation to the hospital. At our initial assessment, patient had a right 7th nerve palsy with House-Brackmann grade of IV, right 5th nerve palsy, and right 6th nerve palsy. Motor and sensory testing elsewhere were normal, although patient had non-specific complaints of shoulder and hip girdle pain with paresthesias into his extremities. Lumbar puncture was performed, which was significant for CSF pleocytosis and eventually CNS Lyme returned as positive. Patient empirically started on IV Ceftriaxone after lumbar puncture and had eventual clinical improvement.